Historical Listing of pastors having served Francis Makemie Presbyterian Church 
During the life of the church Francis Makemie has shared ministers with other churches. At times it was with Clarke Presbyterian, or with Powelton Presbyterian and eventually around 1949 the yoke with Naomi Makemie Presbyterian has been maintained. 

Installed, Supply, Temporary Pastors listed here
 1939-1943 Robert William Kirkpatrick
 1944-1946 Paul Edgar Crane
 1949-1957 George M. Apperson
 1957-1960 Irving Allen Sparks
 1963-1964 Allen Brown
 1964         Graham Reid
 1964-1970 Andrew Tunyogi
 1970-1971 Harold H. Cummings
 1972-1973 Jan Gaylord Owens
 1974-1990 William M. Plonk
 1990 -1991 Donald R. Broad (interim) 
​ 1991 -2000 Elizabeth B. Talbot
 2000 -2001 Donald R. Broad (interim)
 2001 -2002 William  D. Carmines
 2003 -2004 Donald R. Broad  (interim)
 2004 -2006 Eugene Soud  (interim)
 2006 -2013 Robert M. Close
 2014 -​​          Monica Gould